Comments on Habibi Halaqas: In Defence of Prophet's Multiple Marriages (Part 1...

Wa alaykum us salaam, Jazaakillaah khayr for your ...

2012-02-01T03:43:57.292-06:00

Wa alaykum us salaam,
Jazaakillaah khayr for your interesting input. Allaah knows best, I might be wrong about the "fitrah" part - it was just my conclusion based on the research given. I don't think Aadam and Hawwa (a.s.) are relevant examples, though; their children had to marry and mate in order to produce more offspring - and we know that is not fitrah!
I agree that

Dear Khadeejah, Jazaakillaah khayr for your wonder...

2012-02-01T03:09:38.888-06:00

Dear Khadeejah,
Jazaakillaah khayr for your wonderful insight! I totally agree with you that polygamy has nothing to do with spirituality - and also that what worked before will not necessarily be endorsed in today's day and age. What I simply ask for is tolerance towards the fact that at that time, it worked pretty well and no one had any qualms about it, so we don't have the right

Dear Hiba, Your efforts to write about a controve...

2012-01-26T02:15:43.416-06:00

Dear Hiba,

Your efforts to write about a controversial topic is commendable, mashaaAllah! I am waiting for the entire series so that I can have a well-balanced idea about your thoughts on this issue.

In my opinion, polygamy is not and should not be linked with the spirituality that Islam stands for. That polygamy was perhaps best practised in the times of the Prophet (

Masha Allah, looking forward to your next post.

2012-01-26T01:46:21.534-06:00

Masha Allah, looking forward to your next post.

Excellent thoughts dear Guest! Your points have be...

2012-01-26T01:26:44.615-06:00

Excellent thoughts dear Guest! Your points have been raised in this article too: http://muslimmatters.org/2011/07/04/polygamy-rational-or-irrational/
I like the article and the ongoing debate on MuslimMatters site.

asalamualaikum, jazakillahu khayrun for bringing ...

2012-01-25T11:41:00.420-06:00

asalamualaikum,

jazakillahu khayrun for bringing up the issue in this article- i would just like to post my thoughts on the issue:

- In terms of Fitrah of a man to be polygamous- i don't think this is true- as Adam (as) was created and had one wife Hawa (as). I don't think it's correct to say it's fitrah, as we were born from one man and one woman. Because if